Mass Atrocity, Ordinary Evil, and Hannah Arendt

Criminal Consciousness in Argentina`s Dirty War

Mark J. Osiel

View Inside Price: $58.00


February 8, 2002
272 pages, 6 1/8 x 9 1/4
14 b/w illus.
ISBN: 9780300087536
Cloth

Is it possible that the soldiers of mass atrocities—Adolph Eichmann in Nazi Germany and Alfredo Astiz in Argentina’s Dirty War, for example—act under conditions that prevent them from recognizing their crimes? In the aftermath of catastrophic, state-sponsored mass murder, how are criminal courts to respond to those who either gave or carried out the military orders that seem unequivocally criminal?

This important book addresses Hannah Arendt’s controversial argument that perpetrators of mass crimes are completely unaware of their wrongdoing, and therefore existing criminal laws do not adequately address these defendants. Mark Osiel applies Arendt’s ideas about the kind of people who implement bureaucratized large-scale atrocities to Argentina’s Dirty War of the 1970s, and he also delves into the social conditions that could elicit such reprehensible conduct. He focuses on Argentine navy captain Astiz, who led one of the most notorious abduction squads, to discover how he and other junior officers could justify the murders of more than ten thousand suspected “subversives.”

Osiel concludes that legal stipulations labeling certain deeds as manifestly illegal are indefensible. He calls for a significant change in the laws of war to preserve both justice and the possibility of dialogue between factions in such sharply divided societies as Argentina. Osiel’s proposals have profound implications for future prosecutions of Pinochet’s lieutenants, Milosevic’s henchmen, the willing executioners of Rwanda and East Timor, and other perpetrators of state-endorsed murder and torture.

Mark J. Osiel is professor of law at the University of Iowa. He is the author of Mass Atrocity, Collective Memory and the Law and Obeying Orders: Atrocity, Military Discipline, and the Law of War.

“This book scrupulously attempts to define the terms lawyers and moral philosophers will have to use in the future in finding a system of justice to deal with the aftermath of mass murder.”—Colm Toibin, Irish Times


“Yet another major book from one of our nation’s foremost legal thinkers. A masterly study, certain to be of great interest to jurists, political scientists, and humanists.”—William P. Alford, Henry L. Stimson Professor of Law, Harvard University  

“With this latest book, Mark Osiel completes his remarkable trilogy on legal responses to atrocity and takes his place as the leading English-language student of this grim but vitally important subject. In addition to the new light he sheds on Argentina’s Dirty War, Osiel offers a sophisticated and surprising critique of Hannah Arendt’s famous ‘banality of evil’ thesis. His portrait of Alfredo Astiz is chilling, and his analysis of how Catholic theologians relieved the consciences of killers should provoke debate both in and out of the Church. This book is really quite stunning.”—David Luban, Georgetown University Law Center